Criminal Justice & the Rule of Law Executive Branch

James Comey Seeks Dismissal of Indictment, Claims Vindictive Prosecution

Anna Hickey
Monday, October 20, 2025, 5:48 PM
Comey’s lawyers filed a motion to dismiss, citing President Trump’s public attacks.

Published by The Lawfare Institute
in Cooperation With
Brookings

On Oct. 20, James Comey filed a motion to dismiss the indictment against him, alleging vindictive and selective prosecution by the government. 

According to the motion, Comey’s lawyers asserted that, “ample objective evidence–much of which comes directly from government officials’ own public statements and admissions–establishes that the government’s animus toward Mr. Comey led directly to this vindictive and selective prosecution.” 

Throughout the 51 page motion, Comey’s lawyers detail the often adversarial relationship between Comey and the president, citing various Trump’s public statements pushing for the Department of Justice to prosecute the former FBI director. The motion also specifically highlights President Trump’s recent social media post directed at Attorney General Pam Bondi stating that he fired interim U.S. Attorney Erik Siebert for not prosecuting Comey. Trump’s post also directed Bondi to appoint Lindsey Halligan to the position. 

Comey filed this motion alongside an additional motion asking Judge Nachmanoff to dismiss the indictment due to the allegedly unlawful appointment of Halligan to be U.S. Attorney of the Eastern District of Virginia. 

Read the motion here or below. 



Anna Hickey is the associate editor for communications of Lawfare. She holds a B.A. in interdisciplinary studies: communications, legal studies, economics, and government with a minor in international studies from American University.
}

Subscribe to Lawfare