Lawfare Daily: The Trials of the Trump Administration, November 16
Benjamin Wittes, Molly Roberts, Roger Parloff, Anna Bower, and Eric Columbus discuss the latest litigation over Trump administration policies.
In a conversation on YouTube, Lawfare Editor in Chief Benjamin Wittes will sit down with Senior Editors Molly Roberts, Roger Parloff, Anna Bower, and Eric Columbus to discuss the latest litigation over Trump administration policies, including updates on the East Potomac golf course and the triumphal arch cases, the politicization of the Justice Department, a judge’s rejection of the BBC’s motion to dismiss Trump’s defamation suit, the Fourth Circuit’s ruling blocking a DOJ demand for journalists’ LinkedIn data, the D.C. Circuit’s decision protecting U.S. Agency for Global Media head Michael Abramowitz from removal, an immigration roundup, and more.
Find Lawfare’s litigation tracker here.
You can find information on legal challenges to Trump administration actions here. And check out Lawfare’s new homepage on the litigation, new Bluesky account, and new WITOAD merch
To receive ad-free podcasts, become a Lawfare Material Supporter at www.patreon.com/lawfare. You can also support Lawfare by making a one-time donation at https://givebutter.com/lawfare-institute.To receive ad-free podcasts, become a Lawfare Material Supporter at www.patreon.com/lawfare. You can also support Lawfare by making a one-time donation at https://givebutter.com/lawfare-institute.
[Intro] Benjamin Wittes: It is Friday, the 6th of November 2026. It is 10:00 PM in Switzerland, which is to say 4:00 PM in Washington, D.C. And folks, you are watching Lawfare Live, the Trials and Tribulations of the Trump Administration. I know you’ve been focused on elections this week. Excuse me. I know that nobody’s been thinking about litigation this week, but the trials have kept trialing. The tribulations have kept tribulating. None of it paused even for a moment because people were casting votes. Appeals are happening. Temporary restraining orders are temporarily restraining things. And we have followed it so that you don’t have to. You can sit there and watch, you know, Steve Kornacki on the election returns, and we have been poring over the litigation, none of which has been made a louder splash this week than the district government and the, and Virginia counties getting together to enter the fray on the matter of the triumphal arch. [Main podcast] I am here with not one, not two, not three, but four separate Lawfare Senior Editors, Molly Roberts, Roger Parloff, Eric Columbus, and Anna Bower. And I visited with Molly Roberts the other day the site of the soon to be arch. It had not yet been temporarily restrained by Judge Chutkan, but she apparently sensed that we were there and issued a temporary restraining order on a theory of standing, Roger, that I believe we have discussed on this show several times. So, bring us up to speed. What happened? Roger Parloff: Yeah. So, when last we left you, I had just gotten out of a hearing last Friday, October 30th, involving the original plaintiffs in this case who were, remember, trying to stop the arch. They were three Vietnam vets and an architectural historian and Judge Chutkan. That’s been filed since February, and so there was a fully briefed preliminary injunction motion before her. And we all knew that November 5th was supposed to be the day, that’s yesterday, that everything might happen, that the National Capital Planning Commission would formally approve it, the National Park Service would formally approve it, and construction would begin all the same day. And of course, the whole hearing was about standing, which as we’ve talked about, was the challenge, especially after the Supreme Court rejected the standing in the ballroom, challenge to the Trump’s ballroom. And how do you distinguish, part of this was aesthetic injury and then whatever additional injury veterans would feel who want to be buried there and find this revolting idea to have this looming thing standing above. The next day, that was October 31st, finally, a new suit was filed by the D.C. government and the Virginia government, and this is something that Ben had been sort of urging to happen. And they had much stronger standing theories traffic congestion, disruption of emergency response vehicles, environmental issues, possibility of air traffic problems, especially during construction, ‘cause you would need... You’ll need cranes that are gonna be, like, 320 feet high. And so, they were seeking a TRO, a temporary restraining order, a much more compressed timeline. Now, it might seem like, well, wait a minute is waiting for the last minute fair, or should they have— shouldn’t they have brought it earlier? And in fact, it’s sort of the reverse. It’s bizarre, but because of the way the government is litigating these things, and you’ve seen this in Molly’s golf course case, they, regardless of when in fact they know the thing is going forward, they always claim no decision has been made yet. No decision has been made yet. And they do that for two reasons. They do that to say, well, the case isn’t ripe. As a constitutional matter, you don’t have standing if it isn’t ripe. And also, because most of these are being challenged under the Administrative Procedure Act, and you can’t challenge something until there is final agency action, and they’re saying there isn’t final agency action. And so, the case was well-timed, and Judge Chutkan was extremely careful and restrained and reserved and she waited until the very last minute. She did issue orders that said, well, tell me within one hour after the Capital Planning Commission makes its decision, one hour after the National Park Service makes its final decision, and within 30 minutes of any even off-site preparation for actual construction. And so, with that timeline she waited and you know, and it went like clockwork. The Planning Commission approved, NPS approved, and by the way, you know, when they approved, NPS approved, like, with a 57-page opinion. So, it’s like, gee it seems like it might have been decided earlier even though they said this was this... But anyway, and then she issued her I think it was 33-page opinion. And it was, she only ruled on the TRO for the D.C. and Virginia plaintiffs. She held in abeyance the harder case for the vets, which had been pending since February. So, it really was... There was the- Benjamin Wittes: So, she agreed with me, right? Roger Parloff: Yeah. Yeah. There was the stronger standing. There was really, by the time she ruled, there was no dispute about ripeness. They had to agree that there was final agency action. And then she just ruled on one of the theories, the strongest theory. D.C. and Virginia said there were really five statutes that were being violated, but sort of the most obvious was the Commemorative Works Act of 1986, because it says when you do a commemorative structure like this not only does Congress have to approve, but you have to go through a series of administrative procedural hurdles, none of which had occurred, and there isn’t really any dispute about that. As for, you know, the government did have this theory that oh, this was approved in 1925, 101 years ago, when Congress approved the Memorial Bridge. But she didn’t seem to have much problem with dismissing that. The 1925 statute doesn’t mention an arch. There was a 1924 plan that discussed two narrow columns, 166 feet each, widely set, and it says in it, that they, you do that so that you won’t obstruct this very important view between the Lincoln Memorial and the Custis Lee mansion, which is also called Arlington House, which is at the top of Arlington Cemetery. And of course, Trump’s monument is not a column… is not widely set columns and does obstruct that view. You sort of have to look through a keyhole sort of effect to even see either from the other. And also some other... but I think that’s the gist of it. And so, the TRO will last 14 days and in that time, presumably D.C. and Virginia will begin briefing the preliminary injunction, which will last longer. But in the meantime, the TRO is probably not appealable. You know, that was the rule until there have been some exceptions made. Benjamin Wittes: Yeah, the rule is now they’re not appealable except when they are. Roger Parloff: Yeah. And but I think this is so strong I don’t think they’re gonna wanna... so they haven’t appealed it yet, and with a lot of these things, they would have appealed it by now. They usually appeal within an hour, and if that. So, and I assume that, like I that maybe she will rule on the other one as well when the other case as well. There was one other- Benjamin Wittes: So- Roger Parloff: You know, I’m sorry. Yeah, that’s… Yeah, that’s… so that’s it. Benjamin Wittes: So, explain something to me about this. We were... I was discussing this morning with a viewer who said, hey, doesn’t it look a little funny for her to rule that fast? You know, she produces a 33-page ruling inside of an hour. She clearly wrote it in advance. And I sort of said, well, wait a minute. I mean, the government kind of puts her in this position where if you don’t rule, if you rule before they produce the final agency action, even though the president has said they’re gonna do it, even though they’re clearly planning to do it, then it’s not ripe and there’s no final agency action. But if you wait and… a reasonable time afterwards and don’t have your opinion ready to go in advance, then you know, they’ve bulldozed the East Wing or they’ve, you know, uprooted 500 trees. And I’m just trying to think of it from the point of view of a justice who would be inclined toward deference to the executive. And you say, does it look bad for the district judge to have clearly done her homework in advance here and done all the writing? I mean, it’s pretty irregular, right? Roger Parloff: What’s irregular is this government game of saying, we haven’t made the decision. We haven’t made the decision, and then we made it. Boom. And you know, they wait for the wrecking ball to be in motion and then call out, final action. Boom. And so, she does what she has to do to… I don’t see how you could possibly fault that. There’s an even weirder thing right now with ripeness, it which— ‘cause ripeness is apparently supposed to be viewed from the time the case is filed. And so, with respect to the you know, the original plaintiffs, they filed in February, and you would think, well, that’s the more responsible thing to do to, you know, to give the... But ripeness in February is very hard to prove, ‘cause it looking back, it was you can’t prove it wasn’t conceptual, only conceptual back, way back then. And now that we know it’s true, they don’t get the benefit of that unless they file an amended complaint or something. So, it’s all really weird procedurally. But I can’t see anybody faulting her for being ready to go and doing it. Benjamin Wittes: I’ll make you a gentleman’s bet that there is, in the Alito Thomas opinion, some disapproving clucking at the alacrity with which the district court second-guessed the... You know, there’ll be some reference to the elapsed number of minutes. And… in a footnote in the majority opinion affirming her, there will be the point that you and I just made about the inevitability of behaving that way. Roger Parloff: One last thing, and we, I know we need to move on, but I didn’t mention it last time. You know, October 28th in the original case that was like last Wednesday, that was the time that the government, for the very first time tried to inject national security issues into this case. They submitted a Hegseth- affidavit and a Mullen affidavit and they were very vague, but tried to say, you know, well, even though it’s not in the plan, you know, maybe we could put sensors at this high location and it would be really helpful to, and we could have drones and it would defend against enemy drones. And… Benjamin Wittes: If you put a drone on a memorial it makes it a national security- Roger Parloff: Yeah ... Benjamin Wittes: installation. And, there’s doctrine on that ... Roger Parloff: She did not have much... and actually the government lawyer which is Stander, I think he’s also in Molly’s case actually mentioned presidential assassinations at the hearing. I don’t know how the triumphal arch is gonna prevent presidential assassination but I guess the idea maybe with the drone port the counter drone force that would be housed there. But anyway, she did not have much trouble with that one either. Benjamin Wittes: All right. We’re gonna get to Judge… Magistrate Judge Ferucci in just a second, but since we’re talking about important building projects around Washington, I just wanna… Molly and I did also visit the golf course site, and I just have three quick yes or no questions for Molly, which is, did we see any White House staffers getting hit with golf balls or any sign of danger to government officials playing golf at the golf course? Molly Roberts: No. Benjamin Wittes: Okay. Did we see a giant pile of dirt? Molly Roberts: Yes. Benjamin Wittes: How big was it? Molly Roberts: So big that I was not even sure at first whether that could be the pile of dirt that we had discussed. It looked— They’ve put grass on it to mitigate erosion. It looks like a little mountain. It just, it was so large that it seemed permanent to me, but it is indeed the pile of dirt that was dumped there. Benjamin Wittes: Yep. It’s the East Wing. And it is a no joke big pile of dirt. All right. Anna, last week we had lots of discussion of Judge Ferrucci having a preliminary hearing on the case against Ms. Flores and Mr. Benavides. He dismissed the case today, at least temporarily, until the government gets an indictment. What do we know? Anna Bower: Well, he actually dismissed the case on Monday from the bench. There was a plan that the magistrate judge had made the week before after this long three-day hearing in which he said, I’m gonna try to deliver a ruling from the bench at nine AM on Monday morning, so everyone come back then. And you know, Roger and I both unfortunately were out of town, and so neither of us could be there, although we had covered the three previous days. So based on news reports from other reporters who were there, my understanding is that Judge Ferrucci dismissed the case, the complaint against Flores and Benavides and really for like an hour gave a kind of monologue from the bench about this decision. Although from the reports, it wasn’t exactly clear to me what the core of the decision was. There was a lot of quotes in the mainstream media stories about how he kind of went after the government for the fact that it seemed to be a vindictive prosecution in advance of the midterms. But in terms of the substance of the probable cause analysis, I did not get a whole lot of detailed information from the news reporting on that part of it, and we’re still waiting on the transcript. So, I do think it’s important to kind of close the loop on that discussion, but it’s something that we still need to get a little bit more information on because there’s not yet a written order from Judge Ferucci. So, but where it stands now- Benjamin Wittes: And we s- Anna Bower: Go ahead. Benjamin Wittes: We still don’t know whether the government is going to try to get an indictment within 30 days of the criminal complaint, which feels like about two weeks ago or whether they’re just gonna let it rest at this point, right? Anna Bower: We don’t because the government still has, as I understand it, the government still has a few options here. One is that it could draft a new complaint that has you know, potentially new evidence based on this ruling on there being a lack of probable cause from Judge Ferrucci or it could go ahead and go to a grand jury as it was able to do before it actually you know, issued there or sought this complaint in the first place. So, there are still ways that this case could proceed, but you know, I it doesn’t, right now it does not seem that the government is immediately eager to try to appeal to Judge Boasberg. Maybe they’re waiting on that written ruling first, I’m not sure. But you know, it’s not clear to me yet whether they indicated if they would like to appeal this to Judge Boasberg, which would be the next step if they want to try to go that route as opposed to seeking an indictment or, you know, a new complaint. Benjamin Wittes: All right. Speaking of judges who are not happy, Eric Columbus, Judge Perry in Chicago seems very unhappy with the Broadview Six case. Bring us up to speed. Eric Columbus: Sure. The Broadview Six, for listeners who may not remember precisely are a, as you might guess, six people who were protesting in Chicago at- Benjamin Wittes: Well, it started at six. It kept going down. Eric Columbus: It started at six, it kept going down, and then, and as Agatha Christie would say and then there were none. And a group of protesters who were charged with and indicted for, obstructing and attempting to injure a ICE officer who, or attempting to damage the property of ICE, the government, at an immigration protest in, outside of the Broadview detention center, I think it’s what it’s called out in Chicago. And the case fell apart when it emerged that the government had engaged in various grand jury shenanigans. And Judge Perry has been very interested in the veracity or not of representations that have been made to her over the course of the case. And October 9th, she requested that the government produce by October 30th any communications between September 2025 and March 2026 with anyone outside of the U.S. Attorney’s Office regarding any investigatory or charging decisions in the case mainly. And she because the government had sworn up and down that they had no communications with main Justice over this. And she’s interested in this and kind of helping figure out why misrepresentations were made during the grand jury process and other irregularities occurred. And she, you know, her kind of hackles were kind of up thinking that maybe the government is not being, playing straight with them. So that was due October 30th. On October 30th, which is last Friday Stan Woodward, who is the number three official at DOJ and is technically not in charge of criminal matters at all basically had not been involved in this case at all, basically kind of parachutes in and files a brief saying, you know, I hear that you want to conduct some inquiry and get some documents from us. You can’t really do... You’re, one, you’re saying this just as a request, and so we don’t have to give you anything. And two, if you’re gonna request that from us, you better tell us what the reason is for doing this and what the reason is for conducting this inquiry. And that’s Friday. On Monday a couple of things happened. First, the former special agent in charge of the Chicago office of the FBI, who had left his office somewhat unexpectedly I believe over the summer filed suit against Blanche, Patel, the U.S. attorney Andrew Boutros, and argues basically that they pushed him out without cause, and that they made him the fall guy, that Boutros, the U.S. attorney, made him the fall guy for the collapse of the Broadview Six prosecution. And that Boutros noted that his... That this is the guy’s name is Doug DePodesta. And Boutros noted that DiPodesta’s sister-in-law represented one of the defendants and suggested that they conspired to tank the case, which is a pretty serious charge. And he says, you know, this was all nonsense.” DePodesta says, this is all nonsense. They didn’t... I didn’t do any of that at all.” And he includes in his complaint, he says, oh, by the way, I was at a meeting about this case with Blanche and Boutros, and another political appointee whose name I don’t remember in Chicago on or about this date so that’s filed, and obviously we don’t have any evidence as to whether that’s his allegations are correct or not. Later that day Judge Perry issues another order, and she says, in response to Stan Woodward, she says, yes, you know, you’re right. What I said was a request. I was requesting documents. I didn’t have any ability... I wasn’t gonna command them. And part was I figured that you guys would be happy to respond to this because you said up and down that nothing untoward happened. So, I figured that you would say as much, and that nothing... Either that there were, in fact, no such communications as your attorneys have been maintaining to me. And if the in... As she put it, if the involved prosecutors’ statements to the courts were truthful, the documents the court requested would be exculpatory. Generally, attorneys appreciate the opportunity to provide evidence that they have not lied to the court, and the court wanted to provide that opportunity to these prosecutors. And then she’s kind of like dripping with contempt. She says, you know, to be clear, the factual basis for the court’s inquiry is not a mystery to anyone who has had any involvement with this case or even conducted a cursory review of the docket. However, given that the main justice attorney who filed the October 30th response did so immediately after having filed his appearance on the day the response was due, the court will address his professed confusion and give a detailed explanation for the document requests, which she then proceeds to do. And so, it’s... Then after that, she just says, okay, I will give you a few more days. Why don’t I give you until November 6th to produce these documents? And then a couple days later, DOJ files something that, you know, seemed kind of meek and says okay, how about give us till November 9th? And she says, fine. And now she— Oh, and she also ordered, in that order, she also ordered the U.S. attorney and various other prosecutors involved in the case to, testify under oath on November 16th. And shortly after that one of those attorneys one of the line prosecutors, William Hogan files to intervene in the case. And he has lawyered up basically, and he notes that he is doing so because... He notes that the prosecutor who was mainly involved in the grand jury proceedings had already been allowed to intervene because Judge Perry said her interests may not be aligned with the government’s. And then Hogan in intervening now, he says, I’m intervening now, you know, one to, was there one request, a slight delay in the hearing date ‘cause my lawyer’s going to be out of town, but also, I’m intervening because my interests very much may not be aligned with the government’s. So, this is, I mean, it’s this remarkable drama in a case that quite possibly could have been just the fact of prosecutors being overzealous in a way that prosecutors may often be. We just often don’t see the, how the sausage is made before the grand jury because we don’t see the grand jury transcripts. But now it’s looking like this may be a kind of broader scandal implicating political appointees lying to the court about the degree to which mean justice has been putting finger on the scale regarding charging decisions. So that will be a very exciting hearing to watch. It’s currently scheduled for November 16th. Benjamin Wittes: And will you be there? Eric Columbus: I had no plans to. I certainly could. She has done any hearings. Her hearings have not been, broadcast. Benjamin Wittes: Yeah, I think this is this warrants a trip to Chicago. It sounds like good theater Eric Columbus: I hear it’s a great city. Anna Bower: If you can’t go, Eric, I might go. That sounds like- Benjamin Wittes: Yeah. Anna Bower: really interesting stuff. Benjamin Wittes: All right, folks, it has been a big week in the vindictive prosecution Olympics, and I will remind you all that when last we checked in on the all-important vindictive prosecution, you know, competition in this year’s Olympics we still only had one case that was… has actually been thrown out for vindictive prosecution. And so, Kilmar Abrego Garcia is in fact are on the gold medal podium until somebody dethrones him. But remember that Jim Comey and Letitia James only didn’t, have never had their vindictive prosecution motions adjudicated because the prosecutor who they were alleging acted vindictively was illegally appointed. And Kseniia Petrova, AKA frog embryo lady Claude Frog Lady was, you know, had gotten discovery on her vindictive prosecution motion. So, there are a bunch of people kind of nipping at the heels of our leader in this field, and today there’s been— this week there’s been action in a bunch of these cases. Molly, let’s start with you. Smartmatic, which is the head of the corporate vindictive prosecution contestant, they seem to have caught up with Kseniia Petrova and gotten some discovery, yeah? Molly Roberts: Yes. This is interesting to me because I wrote about this, I think, a year ago and then kind of moved slowly, but the thought then was, oh, it’s a long shot, but it might happen. Of course, in the interim, we’ve seen everything you just mentioned, sort of the developments in this area generally, and this is yet another part of the trend because of the trend of prosecutions that look awfully vindictive or selective. So Smartmatic, I imagine pretty much everyone listening has heard of. It’s a company that makes voting machines and a company that has been the subject of conspiracy theories by the right about rigging the 2016 election. And so, this story begins with an investigation of Smartmatic and its parent company during the Biden administration for the role of members of its board, of its executives in a money laundering bribery scheme related to the 2016 Philippine elections. And that investigation ended during the Biden administration in a six-count indictment of a number of its executives, as well as the Philippines’ former elections commission chairman. And those were Foreign Corrupt Practice Act charges and conspiracy charges related. But these charges were not against the company itself. So that case was pending. There were various motions to reschedule and continue. And then, after Trump was inaugurated, the company, Smartmatic, was also indicted in a superseding indictment. And there were a number of reasons this was odd. Some of it just had to do with the investigation and conversations didn’t seem to have been proceeding in such a way that would happen. But more importantly, the administration, pretty much right upon inauguration, had issued a memo, Pam Bondi had issued a memo when she was attorney general, easing up on FCPA enforcement more generally, prioritizing investigations related to terrorism and cartels. And then Todd Blanche, as deputy attorney general, had issued a memo focusing on, saying to focus on individual misconduct rather than attributing malfeasance to corporations. But then, of course, they went ahead and issued this superseding indictment in a case that had focused on individuals indicting the corporation. And at the same time, the administration had dismissed various prosecutions kind of according to this supposed new practice. So, people who have been listening regularly to Lawfare Live will remember we’ve discussed United States versus Adani, the case about the Indian billionaire, where there was a lot of drama between Trent McCotter and the judge. And, you know, this is this guy who happened to pledge a $10 billion investment in the United States. But the administration was saying, well, we’re just not doing as much foreign corrupt practices prosecution, which according to its memos was true. And so Smartmatic is this real outlier here. And so Smartmatic alleged in its motion to dismiss for selective and vindictive prosecution that Trump’s personal animus against the company and its assertion of its rights against people like Rudy Giuliani, Sidney Powell, Jeanine Pirro, Mike Lindell, that whole merry band of misfits that President Trump had animus against it for its assertion of its rights against them because it lodged a lot of defamation cases, some of which are still ongoing. And this works really well with the theories around vindictive and selective prosecution because of these broader Foreign Corrupt Practices Act enforcement rules, right? The vindictive prosecution but-for requirement, you wouldn’t have been prosecuted but for this. It’s a lot easier to show that when you’re saying, well, there’s actually a rule that says don’t do this, or not a rule, but a memo about how the department is going to adjust its practices. And then similar for selective prosecution, the similarly situated individuals, or I guess similarly situated corporations in this case. So, you know, the way that these doctrines work is that if vindictive prosecution isn’t proven outright, actual vindictiveness isn’t proven, the court can find a presumption of vindictiveness, and then the burden falls to the government to rebut it. And for selective prosecution, you have to show facts to create a reasonable doubt about the constitutionality of the prosecution. So, Judge Williams, an Obama appointee in the Southern District of Florida, found enough evidence to grant discovery and look further into the question of whether this was indeed a vindictive and selective prosecution… or elective prosecution. Benjamin Wittes: So, do we think that do we think that Smartmatic is now tied with Kseniia Petrova in there being kind of a prima facie case of vindictiveness, but not, maybe not getting the whole way there yet? Or is she still ahead because, you know, I don’t know, they were engaged in some shady stuff in the Philippines and, you know, they were all this is really a question of which statute you indict- Molly Roberts: Yeah. Benjamin Wittes: individuals on versus the corporation, whereas hers it’s like who gets indicted for carrying lab samples into customs, you know, except in this administration. Molly Roberts: Yeah. Benjamin Wittes: It feels to me like she’s still ahead. Molly Roberts: She’s probably still ahead, and of course, you know, I defer to Anna who’s going to talk about that case. But I think she’s probably still ahead. I mean, you know, in both cases, in this case, yes, there was shady stuff going on and shady stuff going on that seems like it makes sense to prosecute someone for, whereas with Kseniia Petrova, you know, and Anna knows more about the case than I do, maybe arguably there’s some violation of these rules, but it’s not the kind of thing you would ever respond to anyone with that response. So, it seems that she should be ahead, but, you know, it’s somewhat subjective. Benjamin Wittes: All right. But Anna, there have been further developments in the Kseniia Petrova case, and I’m afraid she’s kind of been kicked into Comey Letitia James territory. What happened? Anna Bower: No, I think that Kseniia Petrova is not to Kilmar Abrego Garcia levels, but I would say maybe Kseniia Petrova is one of the winners in the selective or vindictive prosecution Olympics this week because, Ben, her case has now been dismissed following the Justice Department seeking dismissal of the case after the district court judge ordered discovery on her selective or vindictive prosecution motion. And I think that, you know, this is an example of the government being compelled to produce some discovery and then backing off. You know, it’s almost in a way an even better outcome than it was for Kilmar Abrego Garcia because, you know, the government is appealing that decision. Here they’ve gone ahead and on their own volition sought dismissal with prejudice, which the judge then granted the next day. And the part- Benjamin Wittes: But they didn’t get it acknowledging that they had behaved vindictively, whereas- Anna Bower: They did not. No ... Benjamin Wittes: Abrego Garcia gets the decision that says, you know, this was a vindictive prosecution. Anna Bower: Right. Get, gets the decision from the district court judge. Obviously, the government still contests that they are vindictively or did vindictively prosecute Kilmar Abrego Garcia. But in the Petrova case, it follows this order that we’ve discussed on Lawfare Live previously in which the magistrate judge initially ordered discovery on this selective or vindictive prosecution motion. It then went up to the judge and last month, or yes, last month the district court judge upheld that decision. So, she was supposed to get discovery on this issue as well as the grand jury legal instructions. And then the government files this, and it, and its argument here is that, you know, it would take too much, too many resources away from other priorities of the Justice Department to continue to prosecute this case. They said that they anticipate additional discovery disputes. So, they’re you know, saying, we still believe in this case, but we just think that there are more important things for us to prosecute. So, that’s kind of where they left it, but the case has now been dismissed with prejudice against Claude Frog embryo researcher, Kseniia Petrova. Eric Columbus: I found, I just add, I found it very interesting that they filed that motion, I believe, late in the afternoon on Election Day and clearly in an attempt to bury it. Anna Bower: Yeah, they filed it right when the results were coming in. I mean, it, I’m sure that there, it didn’t get as much attention as it maybe would have because of when it was filed. You know, I was watching the results. The first polls had just closed, and I was watching the results when I saw... And shout out to John Hawkinson, who has done a lot of great reporting on this case. I actually saw that John Hawkinson, ‘cause I wasn’t checking the docket at the time or my emails, and I saw that John Hawkinson had tweeted about it. So yeah, it certainly was interesting the timing of when the government sought dismissal. Benjamin Wittes: All right. Meanwhile on the subject of dismissal, there has been a week-long bloodletting at the Justice Department in which large numbers of officials have either been dismissed or have dismissed themselves. In some cases, it can be a little hard to tell which is which. Anna, what do we make of this and what do we think is going on? Anna Bower: Yeah, so this week post-elections in which Democrats swept the House and the Senate in a pretty, you know, devastating, what appears to be a pretty devastating blow to Trump’s policies and administration priorities. In the wake of all of that, we’ve seen several high-profile DOJ officials who have departed. That includes Henry Whitaker who is the senior DOJ official who was handling a lot of the appeals related to appointment of U.S. attorneys handling, for example, the Comey case appeal, the first Comey case appeal, other appeals related to appointments of U.S. attorneys. It also includes Harmeet Dhillon of the Civil Rights Division who was involved in a lot of the election litigation that was by and large, quite unsuccessful, especially related to getting access to voter rolls. It also includes John Eisenberg, who was the head of the National Security Division, and then finally it includes oh gosh, who? Oh, Jason Reding Quiñones, the top prosecutor in the Southern District of Florida, who importantly is the prosecutor whose office was overseeing the grand conspiracy case and who according to reporting by The New York Times and other outlets, there had been a lot of pressure on his office in recent weeks, especially with there being other departures by Joe diGenova and Kurt Olsen, a lot of kind of disarray within the grand conspiracy case that seems to have been stalled now. And so, it, there, the question I think here, Ben, is like what does all of this signal? Is there a pattern here? Are there individual reasons? It’s not entirely clear whether some of these folks might have had you know, their own discrete reasons for leaving the Justice Department. But there is some reporting, at least with respect to Harmeet Dhillon and Jason Reding Quiñones that maybe they were kind of, asked to leave or it was suggested that it was time to go. There’s reporting that Trump apparently saw Harmeet Dillon’s 60 Minutes interview that she recently did and felt that she wasn’t hard line enough on some of the election issues in her interview that they aired. In terms of Jason Quiñones, there’s again, as I mentioned, some reports of discontent within the administration about the failure thus far of the grand conspiracy case to really get off the ground. And the fact that case has seemed to have kind of imploded. Benjamin Wittes: Doesn’t seem to be causing any introspection about whether maybe the case doesn’t have any merit. Anna Bower: Right. And I, my view is maybe that, you know, I think there’s two ways to look at this. One is that some people looking at it from the outside might think, oh, well, these departures could signal a kind of more a moderation of some of the Justice Department’s more extreme positions that it’s been taking, whether it’s, you know, the Civil Rights Division’s efforts around elections or some of the cases that the Civil Rights Division has been leading that are quite dubious, including the Minnesota church case, for example. It might signal that the grand conspire… they’re having second thoughts about the grand conspiracy case. I don’t see it in that way, especially following the news about Steven Miller being promoted to chief of staff. I think, in fact, maybe s- Benjamin Wittes: That clearly reflects a softening of… Anna Bower: I think that in combined with some of these reports that we’re getting that, that actually it was a perceived failure of some of these folks to actually do more and to go kind of more hard line in some of these actions, I think maybe that that is kind of more of the issue as opposed to a moderating in the wake of the election. But I’d be curious... Of course, that’s just speculation. I’d be curious to hear if other panelists have thoughts on that. Benjamin Wittes: Yeah. Molly, what do you make of this in light of your grand conspiracizing experience over the last couple years? Molly Roberts: Yeah, I agree with Anna, so nothing that thrilling to hear from me. The reporting in The New York Times today, I think, was that, and we already knew that Jason Reding Quiñones had been sidelined to a certain degree and that the Department of Justice had sent people in. But the reporting in The Times is that Aakash Singh was essentially running this investigation already. So, I don’t think you see that much difference now. Certainly, I don’t think it means the administration is going to lay off. I would more expect it to be all right, we’re, you know, continuing just to take charge from D.C. and do what the president wants us to do. But I also think that the grand conspiracy as a grand conspiracy has sort of imploded. I would be surprised if we saw it come back as this tightly knit together case, like the kind that Joe diGenova was attempting to pursue, where he did want it actually to be a grand conspiracy tied up with a bow on top in the end. I would think that, you know, we’re gonna continue, if we see indictments, to see individual indictments that are sort of adjacent to this, or at least are focusing on the bad actors, or we’ve gone through all these documents and now we’ve dug up this new thing about— not new thing, but we’ve re-dug up an old thing about Jim Comey and we’re gonna prosecute him for it. Benjamin Wittes: All right. Eric Columbus: Sorry, just to add one thing, and it’s a news that broke after, right after we started. At 4:03 PM, Ben Penn, a excellent scoop machine of Bloomberg Law, published a story saying that Blanche forced out John Eisenberg, the— from the National Security Division because he was dissatisfied in part with Blanche’s work, sorry, with Eisenberg’s work on the media leak cases. And reportedly, Eisenberg was not aggressive enough in going after reporters, and that Eisenberg pushed back a lot on the strategy of subpoenaing reporters directly and trying to get their, you know, their communications. And the story also suggested that Blanche had concerns over Eisenberg’s ability to manage the division, which had been where morale was very low, in large part because they had been forced to spend a lot of time reviewing Jeffrey Epstein’s files. Benjamin Wittes: Right. I— the word that I have heard about the National Security Division is sold for scraps, and I can’t tell you how many times I have heard that phrase used to describe the disposition of the National Security Division. All right, Eric, one thing that has been sold for scraps this week is all of this election litigation that a week ago was heating up and was, you know, threatening the election and, you know, even if it didn’t amount to anything, it was gonna harass all these people. And now it seems like it’s just mostly petered out, although there are still a few threads that are functioning as harassment. Why don’t you walk us through California, Alaska, you know, the various criminal investigations that are lurking about? Give us an overview of where we are. Eric Columbus: Sure, yeah, and this was stuff that seemed extremely exciting and then possibly momentous last week, and that now I think luckily seems to have a lot, be a lot less concerning, but there are still things that could wind up making news in the weeks and months ahead. On, you may recall that in California the Supreme… Department of Justice had been seeking an injunction requiring the state and counties to segregate twenty thousand ballots of alleged non-citizens that DOJ had— DHS rather, had identified, and that they had lost basically in the district court, in the court of appeals, then went back down to the district court, then up to the court of appeals, and on— They lost in the Ninth Circuit a week, two— a week ago today and then they kind of took their time, DOJ, and on Monday morning, filed a suit, filed a motion for an inju— a petition for an injunction pending appeal before the Supreme Court. And it included some rather unusual language I don’t recall the precise words, but language saying like, this office, meaning the Office of the Solicitor General, has been informed that the United States believes that certain people are non-citizens, et cetera, et cetera. Very care— seemingly carefully crafted hedging language distancing the solicitor general, who always represents the United States before the Supreme Court, from, you know, these kinda crazy folks elsewhere in DOJ who are forcing this case upon him. I mean, he, those are not the words he used, but it seemed like that’s what he was trying to convey. And the Supreme Court, you know, kinda took the hint, and in a matter of hours without even calling for a response from the state of California, they denied the motion from the United States, and there were… no dissents were noted. So that was kind of an indication that there, no one was going, coming to save DOJ in their kind of crusade against what they believe is election fraud. And then there was litigation kind of up and down about, on election day itself, about whether DOJ can threaten election administrators with prosecution regarding processing of these ballots. And DOJ had sent letters to people in that, in election offices around the state, and a district court judge in San Francisco had enjoined them from making such threats. A Ninth Circuit panel said, well, you know, it’s okay. You can do it. It reversed the district judge saying it’s okay to do it. The you know, DOJ has the right to make their opinions known even if, as long as they’re not necessarily doing anything. And then that wound up being vacated by the Ninth Circuit, assigned to an en banc panel, but the en banc panel then upheld the panel, because it’s kinda weird. Like, I think there are, like, 26 judges in the Ninth Circuit and 11, but an en banc is consists only of 11, and the- Benjamin Wittes: Yes. Eric Columbus: ... en banc- Benjamin Wittes: And then there’s super en banc. Eric Columbus: Ah, you’re stealing my thunder here. And the 11 happened to be a six-five Republican majority, a Republican-appointed majority. And then the plaintiffs sought a super en banc review, which is a review by all 26 judges, which has never happened, and I think this might have been only the fourth time that someone has asked for it, and it was denied. I would guess in part, one reason is that, you know, at a certain point, if you really care about something, just ask the Supreme Court to grant you relief. And the stakes were probably perceived as also as relatively low here, and I think the stakes are now kind of swiftly approaching zero, as I don’t think the DOJ really has much stomach for going after these folks. Although, again, you know, Steven Miller being appointed means that anything could happen. But again, the again, on the other hand, the relief requested was merely about kind of threatening, and it wouldn’t seem to preclude, you know, an actual indictment being sought through, you know, different and obviously more secret process. And then finally, DOJ’s been sending out more subpoenas as part of this investigation to various election administrators. So, they clearly are not, they’re sending a variety of mixed signals, shall we say, and it remains to see what will happen. Moving now to Alaska, where the Department of Justice, had, as I discussed last week in some depth, mounted a rather ridiculous lawsuit trying to enjoin the State of Alaska from certifying the results because of the inclusion of two, of a fake— not fake, but of a decoy Dan Sullivan as Republicans, some Republicans have put it, on the ballot to, allegedly to confuse voters. And the district court dismissed that suit on earlier this week, I think it was on Monday, and… finding that there’s basically nothing that a, DOJ did not have standing because there was, it was just simply not redressable. There was nothing that a court could do to remedy the concern. And the DOJ’s issue had to been like, look, what we want to do is to make sure that there’s not certif— to not certify the election only if it turns out that the real Dan Sullivan lost because some people voted for the fake Dan Sullivan because they were confused about who they were voting for. And the court was basically like, well, there’s absolutely no way you could figure that out, and so there’s no relief that we could order that would get you what you want, and therefore, there is no standing. And DOJ appealed that but it just seemed like a box-checking exercise was they had not sought any injunction pending appeal. So, the briefing schedule literally goes through January, and that’s not very much use to them because the certification is gonna take place next you know, later this month probably or early December. So, unless that changes, then the suit is basically dead. Finally, in Washington State there’s a district court judge who also ordered DOJ to stop threatening election officials. I don’t know if DOJ is gonna challenge anything there. It would seem to be whatever threatening has occurred has already happened, and the case is kind of probably moot. But anyway, that order was issued a couple days ago. So, you know, hopefully, this all has ended with a bang, not with a bang, but with a whimper. But we’ll be following that to see whether that’s the case. Benjamin Wittes: What about the various target letters that DOJ has sent out? There were something like twenty of them. Eric Columbus: Ah. I forgot about that. Thank you, thank you. Yes, in Alaska, I forgot to mention that. So yes, and this is kind of remains on the table because the question of whether any laws were, any federal laws were broken as a result of the effort that, according to The New York Times story, appears to have actually been real, actually occurred, that various people in the world of the Peltola campaign and the Democratic congressional efforts more broadly did apparently try to find a decoy Dan Sullivan and convince him to run for governor. And, you know, were any laws broken? I think there have been some chatter and some, actually some senators suggesting that this could violate 18 U.S.C. 241, a rather vaguely worded statute about conspiracy against rights that was actually used to prosecute Trump after the 2020 election. And this could be something that, you know, it doesn’t, there’s no time limit on it. It doesn’t depend on the election, the outcome of the election itself. It’s you know, an attempted murder statute. It doesn’t matter- Benjamin Wittes: Eric, I’m gonna cut you off here. Eric Columbus: Okay. Benjamin Wittes: Because I don’t wanna give this too much seriousness. Eric Columbus: Sure. Benjamin Wittes: Can we agree that recruiting a candidate, even if you did it with specific intent to confuse voters, I’m recruiting you, Eric Columbus, to run against Senator Eric Columbus because I moronically think that some voters will confuse the two of you. And if I did that knowing and intending that people would be confused, that wouldn’t come close to violating the conspiracy against rights statute because nobody has a right to vote for the incumbent unconfused by the fact that somebody who’s also legitimately has the same name also went through the process of being on the ballot. What am I missing? Eric Columbus: Well, the counterargument would be that the right to vote is meaningless if you are— if sand is being thrown in your face and you don’t know who you’re voting for. Benjamin Wittes: Which would be a great argument if the person weren’t really named Dan Sullivan. But he has a right to run for Senate. Eric Columbus: Yes. Benjamin Wittes: And he has a right to run for Senate without changing his name. Look, I disapprove- Eric Columbus: Yes. Benjamin Wittes: ... of what they did. It’s a dirty trick. But it’s— I mean- Eric Columbus: Yes, I mean… Benjamin Wittes: it is— Eric Columbus: the conspiracy is to- Benjamin Wittes: How can you say that getting somebody to exercise his constitutional right to run for office under his actual name in a fashion that does not deceive anybody is a conspiracy against somebody else’s rights? Eric Columbus: Yeah, I think that’s the likeliest outcome. I mean, there’s language in some decisions that say, you know, you have— this has to be not clearly established, but kind of similar language you know, the right being kind of violated, and it would seem to raise kind of, you know, maybe First Amendment issues on on the flip side of terms of the Democrats’ efforts to get people to run who legitimately want to run and run under their own name, as you say. Benjamin Wittes: All right. I will just also say that sending a target letter at a preliminary stage of an investigation is an almost unheard of thing to do. Eric Columbus: Yes. Benjamin Wittes: And to send out twenty of them you send out a target letter when you are notifying somebody that you intend to seek their indictment, and they simply can’t possibly have done an investigation at the level of thoroughness that it would take to know they are gonna indict twenty people. I— Again, I don’t approve of the underlying behavior at all. I don’t think campaigns should be engaged in stuff like that, but that’s a real abuse of the criminal process. Eric Columbus: Yeah. And I think it’s an audience of one issue. Benjamin Wittes: I think that’s right. All right. We are about to lose one of our panelists, but before we do, Molly, one of the questions, currently the only one of the questions in the Q&A is directed at you, and so I’m gonna pose it to you out of sequence here so that we can get an answer before you have to turn into a puff of smoke. Why can’t plaintiffs in the golf course case sue under NEPA demanding an environmental assessment before work begins? I don’t think a final agency action is needed under NEPA. Is the questioner right about that, or is, does NEPA require a final agency action? Molly Roberts: Yeah. So, in this case, and I believe this has to be how it is, NEPA is under the APA. The NEPA claim is proceeding under the APA. It’s an APA claim, Administrative Procedure Act. And so, it then does require a final agency action, and I’m pretty sure that’s how NEPA claims have to work. At least for the most part, there might be some clever ways around it in particular cases if there are statutes with specific length. Anyway, but I— in this case, and I believe generally, that’s how it has to work. NEPA doesn’t have its own, like, private right of action, like, doesn’t have a citizen suit provision unlike other environmental acts, and so it has to go under the APA. So, I think that’s the answer to the question. If anybody knows more about it than I do, please say something. But I am fairly positive that is why and that, yeah, otherwise. I imagine that the plaintiffs would be demanding that the NEPA procedure take place now, but they can’t. Well, they can if you think there’s been final agency action, but- Benjamin Wittes: Right. All right. Thank you. Anna, talk to me about The Wall Street Journal’s… President Trump’s suit against The Wall Street Journal for defamation over the Epstein matter, which seems to have been finally dismissed. What’s going on? Anna Bower: Yeah. So, this week, a judge dismissed Trump’s suit against The Wall Street Journal and some of its reporters over the Epstein birthday letter, the one that had the hand-drawn image of what appeared to be a nude woman and the poem that was quite strange. And the judge had previously dismissed in part the case, and then Trump filed an amended complaint. This time around, the case has been dismissed with prejudice and the judge found that it failed to sufficiently allege actual malice. And just to give you a sense of kind of how weak some of Trump’s arguments on the actual... or allegations on the actual malice prong were in his amended complaint, it was things like The Wall Street Journal failed to seek to interview Ghislaine Maxwell, and if they didn’t include it in their reporting. And it cited the fact that Ghislaine Maxwell put or told Todd Blanche in the interview that he did with Ghislaine Maxwell that she did not remember Trump signing that birthday letter. Now, not remembering signing a birthday letter is not the same thing as saying that Trump did not sign the birthday letter. And so, the judge is kinda like, well, a reporter isn’t obliged to speak to everyone who might know something about the subject of their reporting, so that’s not sufficient to allege actual malice. And then also, even if they did speak to Ghislaine Maxwell, you know, it wouldn’t even really be helpful because she said she didn’t remember whether Trump signed the birthday letter. So, that’s just one example of the kind of thing that Trump was pointing to. There were other things, too, as similar to his complaints about 60 Minutes and the BBC. You know, there’s part of this complaint that says, oh, well, The Wall Street Journal didn’t put everything that it could’ve reported into its piece. And, the court was well, a journalist isn’t required to include all of that. There’s no... so that’s not sufficient. So, it went through all those things, ultimately found that the complaint should be dismissed and did so with prejudice. Trump still has some of some cases that are ongoing against other media outlets including the BBC over the January 6th speech. There’s still a lot of discovery back and forth that’s going on in that case. But here we have an example where these apparently frivolous claims that Trump has made has been thrown out. Eric, I would be curious if you have thoughts about this because I know that you have covered it as well. Eric Columbus: You know, I think everything you said is right on the money. I just think it’s just so interesting about how you know, looking back, how eagerly people fell over themselves you know, corporate defendants to appease Trump and settle cases such as 60 Minutes you know, pay like 15 million or something and where Trump sued about their allegedly not airing in the entirety of a interview with Kamala Harris. You saw Twitter bend the knee to Trump when he sued challenging his... him being kicked off of Twitter. ABC settled regarding a… some comments with George Stephanopoulos. They may have had a little bit more exposure there, but it seemed like they didn’t hesitate that much before settling. And then you saw the tide kind of really turn where eventually with the suits against The Wall Street Journal, this one, and then against the BBC, where eventually media organizations were like, you know, began treating Trump like a normal relatively normal frivolous plaintiff. Benjamin Wittes: Yeah. It’s an interesting question what triggered that change and whether it was the route by the law firms of Trump on First Amendment grounds, which are obviously not defamation, but they’re kind of flavored similarly. And I wonder if watching, you know, four law firms win those cases and Harvard win those cases so decisively came to make the capitulation by one media organization after another look embarrassing. All right. Once upon a very long time ago, oh, my children. The man who is now president faced a criminal charge in New York. In fact, he faced 34 of them. And you may not remember this because it happened so long ago, but there was a trial with a jury and a judge who had white hair and whose appearance the president was very impressed by and talked about how handsome he was a lot. And there were witnesses and lawyers and arguments, and at the end of this trial, the president was convicted of all 34 of those charges at which point he got elected president and we all decided to forget about it, except the president, who has continued to appeal this case. And this week, the First Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York heard oral arguments in the case of State v. Trump. How did it go, guys? Anna Bower: Yeah. So just to remind everyone because it’s, you, to understand how it went, you unfortunately have to remind yourself of the legal theory behind these 34 felony counts that Trump was convicted of. And I say unfortunately because it is a little bit complicated when you go through the different kind of routes of the elements that the DA had to prove here. And everyone seems to always get it wrong. So just to remind everyone, the falsification, the alleged falsified records that Trump was charged with falsifying related to these payments to Michael Cohen that were allegedly internal records that were allegedly mislabeled as for legal services as opposed to reimbursements for payments to Stormy Daniels. And to, for this to be a felony, it was charged under New York law as falsification of business records in the first degree, which requires that not only have business records been falsified with intent to defraud, but that intent to defraud included intent to commit another crime or to aid in the concealment or commission thereof. So that bit raises the question, what is the other crime that Trump tried to commit or conceal by falsifying these records? And the DA, Alvin Bragg, alleged that Trump had intent to commit or conceal the commission of New York Election Law 17 152, which basically criminalizes a conspiracy to promote or prevent the election of any person to a public office by unlawful means. So, the alleged conspiracy here was this conspiracy between Trump, Cohen, and David Pecker to help Trump’s 2016 campaign for president by concocting this catch and kill scheme to cover up negative stories about Trump ahead of the election. And there were three unlawful means that the jury could consider in determining whether there was this intent to conspire by unlawful means to promote Trump’s candidacy. That included violations of the Federal Elections Campaign Act, falsification of other business records or violations of tax laws. And Judge Merchan, or excuse me, Justice Merchan, decided that the jury didn’t have to be unanimous about which of these unlawful means Trump, you know, intended with respect to that element. It’s just that they had to make a general finding that there was an intent to defraud that included intent to kind of conceal or cover up this conspiracy by unlawful means. So, all of that is relevant to the arguments that were before the appeals court in New York now because the main argument that that Robert Giuffra, who is Trump’s new counsel now that his former counsel is the attorney general of the United States, the main argument that he is going with, both in the brief and then also at the oral argument this week, is that the federal… the Federal Election Campaign Act, has an express preemption provision that basically says, you know, anything in this act supersedes and preempts any provision of state law with respect to the election of a federal officer. So, the argument there is that by allowing the jury to consider that one of the unlawful means was a FECA violation that that should have been preempted by federal law and that the conviction, you know, should be reversed. The other arguments include this challenge to the fact that Justice Merchan didn’t require the jury to be unanimous on the unlawful means. And then finally, we have a presidential immunity argument that came up because as we’ve discussed before, there was testimony by Hope Hicks, who was in the, on the communications team at the White House. It was a conversation that she testified about with, that she had with Trump in the Oval Office. There was testimony by a former White House administrative assistant, Madeleine Westerhout, and then there are also several tweets that Trump tweeted while he was president. So, there’s this argument that they have that all of that under the Supreme Court’s immunity decision, even though it found that, you know, for unofficial acts a president could be prosecuted, it also said that evidence of official acts can’t be introduced even in a prosecution that is about unofficial acts. So, the argument there is that’s structural error and the conviction must be reversed. On all of these, Ben, I did not hear... There’s five justices of the new first division that are considering this, or excuse me, first department. I did not hear three votes for any one of those main arguments. There was by my count… Most of, the justices seemed most concerned with the FICA preemption argument here. And I think actually some of them might have been a little bit confused about exactly how FICA plays into the elements here. It seemed like they thought the other crime ... It seemed like they had the impression, at least some of them at first, that Trump was accused of falsifying business records to cover up a FICA violation, and that was, you know, kind of one of the elements of it. But that’s, as I’ve just said, that’s actually not the way that the DA constructed its legal theory. It’s that FICA could have been one of the unlawful means. So, it’s a little bit gets in the weeds to understand it but the person who was representing the DA’s office, an attorney whose last name is Wu, did a really good job of redirecting them, I thought, when it came to kind of understanding what is going on here and why this isn’t a direct kind of regulation. Their argument is that this isn’t a direct regulation of federal campaign contributions, which is when something would be preempted. In fact, it’s a state you know, protecting against concealment of a conspiracy to influence elections, and that FICA is just kind of one way that the jury could have found evidence of unlawful means. Benjamin Wittes: Right. So, if you, if we say there aren’t three votes for any one of these three theories just as the jury does not have to be unanimous as to which of the unlawful means the appellate judges actually don’t have to be unanimous as to which grounds they would throw out the conviction on. And so could you take one from tab A, two from tab B, and a third from, a fourth, from tab C and get a majority that doesn’t agree on the reasons why the case should be thrown out, but does agree on the fact that it should be thrown out? Anna Bower: Not that I could tell, but I will say I listened to this audio only. And so, it’s a little bit difficult when you’re only listening to audio to tell exactly who is asking which questions. But I didn’t get the sense that this... and I’m hesitant to say this because of the fact that I was only listening to the audio, but I did not get the sense that in any event, even if it’s piecing different people with different theories together, that there would be more than two votes for reversing. That said, you know, on the immunity part, which actually wasn’t as much of this argument as I thought it would be, they really did seem to focus mostly in large part on the Federal Election Campaign Act preemption stuff. But on the immunity stuff, you know, regardless of what they decide, it’s going to be a first instance decision about this question of even if they find that these were official acts that were introduced in evidence at in a prosecution of unofficial acts, the question is whether is that automatically reversible, as Trump’s team argues, or do you do a harmless error analysis- Benjamin Wittes: Right. Anna Bower: where you say, yeah, like, it was an official act, so it shouldn’t have been introduced, but it was harmless, so therefore no, you don’t have to reverse. And- Benjamin Wittes: Look, that question, no intermediate appellate body in the New York- Anna Bower: Right ... Benjamin Wittes: state system is gonna be the… you know, any answer they give to that is interim. Even the New York Court of Appeals can’t answer that, ‘cause you need to... The only person who can answer that question is John D. Roberts, because he’s the only person in the world who knows what he meant in that opinion, Anna Bower: Yeah, and that’s exactly my point ... Benjamin Wittes: if in fact e- Anna Bower: Mm-hmm ... Benjamin Wittes: even if he knows what he meant. All right. So, I guess we’ll now wait for another six months while they write an opinion about this, right? Anna Bower: Yeah. I’ll have the great joy of six months from now having to remind myself- Benjamin Wittes: To read it ... Anna Bower: what the legal theory- Benjamin Wittes: Yeah. Anna Bower: ... was here, so I can explain it all again. Benjamin Wittes: All right, Roger, let’s finish up with this week’s immigration roundup. An Egyptian national who was seeking withholding of removal did not get his removal withheld. He got sent to Equatorial Guinea, where he is being held at gunpoint and beaten and sounds like a bad business. Roger Parloff: Yeah. This is one of those cases you’ve probably seen some coverage of that hotel in Equatorial Guinea. I think it was... It’s been on several TV report. I think 60 Minutes recently had it. This man whose initials are A.M.A.S. He is an Egyptian, and he came here in 1998 as a child. He a child of a religious worker. And in 2021, he became a legal permanent resident. And then in 2023, he was convicted of aggravated assault and possession of a synthetic narcotic went to jail for two and a, or was sentenced to two and a half years. He was placed then in removal proceedings by the Biden administration in 2024. He was found removable in October of 2025 by… but granted withholding under CAT, the Convention Against Torture because of fear of that he would be tortured if sent back to Egypt. Sexual orientation, politically prominent family, those entered into the reasons. So, while he was in prison in April, he brought a habeas. And before the habeas got very far, they removed him to Equatorial Guinea one of those third country removals. And as he was being bundled into the plane, he asked for a fear-based, an interview of about his fear-based claims of being sent there, and was told that there was no time for that. He apparently… he moved Equatorial Guinea had given diplomatic assurances. And you remember that the… one of the Trump administration’s favorite theory for removing people to third countries is to pay the country, and they give what’s called a diplomatic assurance that he won’t be harmed in the country, or not just him, because they’re sending dozens of people to these countries that nobody will get harmed here. And also they won’t be refooled or refouled resent back to the country that they’re not supposed to be sent to. And then the State Department says, yes, we find that credible. So, he actually, or dropped that suit at that point. But when he got to Equatorial Guinea, he was put in this hotel, and he was handcuffed and assaulted and held at gunpoint. And there was a Reuters story he— and he cooperated with the Reuters story about the conditions in this place. And then he and several others were bound with rope and hooded and beaten again and held in communicado. And so, people on his behalf brought a new habeas in September. Main... And it came before a Trump appointee in the district of Arizona named John Hinderaker. And he did not like these, what he was seeing, and he ordered, the government to facilitate his, the man’s return, AMAS’s return. And basically, and for 23 days since then nothing he, it’s very, they, it’s been very hard to find out the information that Hinderaker would like the government to provide. Like, do you know where he is? And is he healthy? And what’s his condition? And there’s been a report that, well, he was injured in a vehicle collision, and he can’t get straight answers. And so, he issued additional orders seeking more and more information, and he was in the middle of a hearing, I guess, this week November 2nd and the plaintiff informed, the government informed the judge that the Ninth Circuit has issued a stay. It has vacated his more detailed order, and he, it has stayed his original order to facilitate his return. And the panel was all Democratic appointees. It was Bill Fletcher under Clinton, Roopali Desai under Biden, de Alba, Ana de Alba, a Biden appointee. And I’m sure they’re all concerned about jurisdiction stripping issues. Benjamin Wittes: Right. Roger Parloff: And so, that is the very sad end of my account of that case. Benjamin Wittes: Well, let’s go from that to another very sad matter, which is that we do continue to be deporting people to Iran notwithstanding… including people who have credible asylum claims, notwithstanding that we are, you know, in a war with Iran. And that has been the subject of litigation between an Iranian human rights group or immigration group and the State Department. So, what has developed in that regard? Roger Parloff: Well, this is like you said, this was filed in July. It’s in front of Judge Reyes and, you know, as is true of Judge Reyes, she’s really, you know, very restrained in everything but her rhetoric. She’s very careful and you know, they wanted the group or the Iranian American Legal Defense Fund wanted a TRO and then a preliminary injunction. They said that the government was still sending Iranians to Iran, that it had been also providing confidential information to the Iranian liaisons about these individuals in the process of trying to send them there, information that, you know, would get them killed or tortured, you know, about being non-Muslim, being a dissident, being… their sexual orientation. And but Judge Reyes did not see the goods at that time. They didn’t have firm evidence. She didn’t know even if there had been mistakes made, that was it really a policy? They hadn’t proven any policy. And so, she didn’t enter any of those things. There was a hearing, and all we knew in the beginning was that there had been deportations as recently as December and January before the war, but we thought that there was no longer any interactions. Now we know that there are still interactions, apparently. There’s evidence that there are I think hundreds of emails. And the Iranian— The way this works is the I— There’s an Iranian interest section at the Pakistani embassy, and that’s how we interact with the Iranian government here. And so, on October 15th, evidence was presented to her, and I think the government conceded that it intended to deport more Iranians to Iran. A plaintiff said 12 had been contacted by this Iranian interest section. And Judge Reyes was quite exercised. He said and what you’re telling me is... And I’m getting this, by the way, I believe I’m getting it from Reuters. I did not go to that hearing, and I haven’t yet ordered the transcript, which was recently unsealed. I believe... I’m really sorry if it’s not Reuters, ‘cause, or it might be The Guardian. I think it’s The Guardian. And so, she said and what you’re telling me is that the United States of America is going to send individuals back to that region facing what you and I and everyone who would ever look at this would know would be, at a minimum, a serious threat of certain death. And the government attorney answers, yes, Your Honor. The government is executing lawful orders of removal. So, what she has done is sort of like in the Golf case. That’s an awful comparison, but she has said you need to give me five days notice before you deport anybody, and I think 24 hours notice after deciding to try to deport somebody. But- Benjamin Wittes: So, it really is like the Golf course case. Roger Parloff: It really is. And it’s... And they’re... And the government’s got basically the same response, which is, you have no jurisdiction, and so I assume there’ll be and that’s why you don’t have a TRO or a, you know, preliminary injunction. There isn’t the evidence yet. So, how are you giving these orders about notice? But anyway it’s... it too is... I do... I have to get the transcript, and- Benjamin Wittes: Right ... Roger Parloff: but it’s at a very unsatisfying point. [Outro] Benjamin Wittes: On that cheerful note, this podcast is part of Lawfare’s Live stream series, The Trials and Tribulations of the Trump Administration. All these— Although these particular trials and tribulations seem to be trials and tribulations of victims of the Trump administration. You can subscribe to Lawfare’s YouTube channel to receive an alert the next time we go live. The Lawfare Podcast is produced by the Lawfare Institute. Thanks this week to Eric Columbus, to Roger Parloff, to Anna Bower, and to Molly Roberts for joining us. You can get ad-free versions of this and other Lawfare podcasts by becoming a material supporter of Lawfare at our website, lawfaremedia.org/support, and you really should do that. You know— Only you know if you’re one of those free riders who’s been, you know, getting it all free off of other people’s charitable contributions. But if that’s been gnawing at your heart, as it should, you know, you can come into the light at any time, and you’ll also get access to special events and other content available only to our supporters, like, for example, the ability to ask Molly Roberts questions about the golf course case. This podcast is edited by Goat Rodeo, and our audio engineer this episode, for the first time, is Alina Bondarenko of Lawfare. Our theme music is from Alibi Music. And as always, thanks for listening.
