Today's Headlines and Commentary
The US is bracing for the expected release today of the most extensive review of CIA intelligence-gathering tactics “in generations.” The report is expected to be released at around 11:15 AM, right as Senator Dianne Feinstein, the Chairperson of the Senate Intelligence Committee, is scheduled to address the body’s floor.
Published by The Lawfare Institute
in Cooperation With
The US is bracing for the expected release today of the most extensive review of CIA intelligence-gathering tactics “in generations.” The report is expected to be released at around 11:15 AM, right as Senator Dianne Feinstein, the Chairperson of the Senate Intelligence Committee, is scheduled to address the body’s floor. While the full document, which totals approximately 6,000 pages and 38,000 footnotes, will not be released, the public will be provided with its 480-page executive summary, in addition to a shorter Republican counter-assessment and the CIA’s own assessment.
Reportedly included in the report are “graphic details” about sexual threats and other interrogation tactics that the CIA employed on captured militants. In advance of the report’s controversial findings, the US military has put thousands of troops “on alert” amid fear that the disclosures could precipitate a violent backlash in countries worldwide. Additionally, some Republican lawmakers, citing “domestic and foreign intelligence reports,” have warned that a detailed account of the agency’s interrogation methods under George W. Bush’s administration could cause attacks against US military and diplomatic installations and possibly the death of Americans. While the White House has been outwardly supportive of the disclosures, US Secretary of State John Kerry did call Senator Feinstein last Friday and asked her to consider the timing of release.
Foreign Policy reports that in response to the report, former spies at the CIA have launched a website to rebut the report: CIAsavedlives.com. In a more official reaction to the alleged abuses, the secretive agency said that it “policed” its interrogators and referred over 20 cases of wrongdoing. Additionally, with regards to spies who worry that the new report will paint “targets” on their backs, the CIA is offering new security checks meant to help ensure their personal safety.
Time is out with a how-to guide for reading the report. It suggests readers focus on the facts, not the mutual recriminations, and look for answers to these questions: 1) what was done; 2) was it worth it; and 3) who screwed up?
In addition to our own commentary guide, Lawfare has also provided an outline of what readers can expect from our analysis of the document.
If you are looking for early commentary on the report, here is a list:
- “Pardon Bush and Those Who Tortured” (By Anthony D. Romero, appears in the New York Times)
- “The Insane Narrative You Are Supposed to Believe About the Torture Report” (By Daniel W. Drezner, appears in the Washington Post)
- “Releasing the Feinstein Report on the CIA in the Middle of a War Would Be an Act of Exceptional Recklessness” (By Michael Gerson, appears in the Washington Post)
- “The Problem with the Torture Report” (By Micah Zenko, appears in Foreign Policy)
- “Waterboarding’s Role in Identifying A Terrorist” (By Marc A. Thiessen, appears in the Washington Post)
- “Dick Cheney Was Lying About Torture” (By Mark Fallon, appears in Politico)
- “Former US Spy Officials Divided on Merit of ‘Enhanced Interrogation Techniques’” (By Jeff Stein, appears in Newsweek)
- “Accountability is Needed for Bush-era Torture (By Jameel Jaffer and Ben Wizner, appears in McClatchy)
ICYMI: Yesterday, on Lawfare
Tara Hofbauer alerted us to newly declassified documents demonstrating that the government filed an application with FISC to extend the NSA’s telephony metadata collection program by 90 days.
Wells Bennett linked us to video of yesterday’s oral argument in Smith v. Obama, a challenge to the NSA’s call records program.
Matt Waxman commented on a recent silver lining for GITMO policy. Finally, Bruce Schneier shared his thoughts on new reports of operations AURORAGOLD and NSA hacking of cell phone networks. Email the Roundup Team noteworthy law and security-related articles to include, and follow us on Twitter and Facebook for additional commentary on these issues. Sign up to receive Lawfare in your inbox. Visit our Events Calendar to learn about upcoming national security events, and check out relevant job openings on our Job Board.
Ben Bissell is an analyst at a geopolitical risk consultancy and a Masters student at the London School of Economics. He graduated Phi Beta Kappa from the University of Virginia with majors in political science and Russian in 2013. He is a former National Security Intern at the Brookings Institution as well as a Henry Luce Scholar, where he was placed at the Population Research Institute in Shanghai, China.